sdaggett Blog

The Importance of an Agency Record - Court Finds that Yellowstone Grizzly Bears Still Need ESA Protection

Attorney Authors: 

In 2007, the Greater Yellowstone Coalition (“Coalition”) filed a lawsuit against the U.S. Fish and Wildlife Service (“Service”), Greater Yellowstone Coalition Inc. v. Servheen, challenging the Service’s final rule (“Rule”) to remove the Yellowstone distinct population segment of grizzly bears from the Endangered Species Act’s threatened species list.  The Coalition prevailed on summary judgment, convincing the district court that two key grounds supporting the Rule – 1) adequate regulatory mechanisms were in place to protect the grizzly and 2) declines in whitebark pine did not threaten the grizzly - were not rationally supported by the record.  The Ninth Circuit Court of Appeals affirmed in part and reversed in part, reiterating the importance of a well-documented Agency record.